Quote:
Originally Posted by Tombstoner
I'm not a height fetishist or knee-jerk loather of blue glass, but I have to admit to getting a bit tired of blue glass boxes that aren't making much effort. The quality of glass may be nice, the street/river-level engagement isn't bad, but for a PRIME location in Chicago, it strikes me as a wasted opportunity to make a statement other than "I'm not offensive" or "it could have been worse." In 5 years no one is going to be thinking about this building as an architectural accomplishment.
|
We all feel this way more or less but I would love to talk to someone from Pelli or whoever is on this project to understand their constraints. I am sure the Pelli team is all skyscraper nerds and would love a 1000 ft+ tower, and they originally designed a much taller tower (though probably before digging into engineering details etc). But IIRC there is a two view corridor that must be preserved for the Apparel Center. So that leaves a relatively small footprint for the building. Being commercial, it needs a lot of elevators. As you can see the core is already 50%+ of the first 40 floors and the building is only 60 floors.
Given that towers are 'one way in one way out', things get much worse as you go higher. The only way it could have been supertall I think would maybe have been all residential which has a lower elevator ratio, which I think would have been a disappointment given the location. I'm still holding out for finding out the real reasons for the height reduction from a reputable source one of these days.