Quote:
Originally Posted by Crawford
Peter Luger, yeah, it's a steakhouse. Not sure why any reviewer would even bother reviewing a standard steakhouse. There's nothing coming out of the kitchen that couldn't be cooked by any sentient human. Steak, fried potatoes and creamed spinach aren't worth reviewing.
For NYC steakhouses, I like Strip House, STK or Quality Meats, but they're all more alike than different, and I don't see the point of going if it isn't for business or some required social event.
|
I've been able to cook awesome steaks that are usually better than ones from great steakhouses. It comes down to good meat and patience.
No, I don't use dry-aged steak. But I do use USDA Prime loin steaks that I buy in bulk at Costco during their Black Friday sale (roughly $10-15 per lb after sale, depending on the size of package). You can overcook these steaks and they will still come out great.
Second is patience. I pat the steak dry using paper towels. Then I salt the steak and put it on a rack over a plate to dry out further in the fridge. After a day in the fridge, the salted steak gets put in a ~200F oven to slow bake at low temps via the "reverse sear" method. This takes about 30 minutes to 1+ hr, depending on the size & thickness of the steak. NOTE: the "reverse sear" method only works on thicker steaks 1.5" or thicker.
Then I heat a cast iron pan for several minutes until it is smoking. I guess you can get a infrared thermometer to get the surface temp of the cooking surface, but it's not necessary. Rub your choice of oil over the entire steak, then cook each side about 45 seconds to 1 minute to get a nice sear all over. Add some butter after the initial sear if you want.
This steak actually doesn't even need ground pepper or sauce, but you can add if you want. I used to add pepper with salt prior to refrigeration, but it's not necessary, and it can even add unpleasant burnt notes after searing.
I left my last steak in the oven too long, and it ended up medium. It was still exceptionally delicious. Salting the steak 1 day in advance really helped.
Speaking of Quality Meats, I recently had the "porterhouse for 2" special at the more casual Quality Eats in UES. They ruined the steak by charring it way too much. It was like eating a steak coated with charcoal. I always hated steakhouses who did that. No one wants a burnt steak.