Quote:
Originally Posted by someone123
Another aspect of this is that Canada publishes data on the border crossings. The positivity for fully-vaccinated border crossers lately has been a little under 0.2%. In other words, 500 PCR tests must be done to find 1 positive. That's $75,000 at current prices around here.
(Meanwhile in BC we do ~0 random PCR testing of the population that isn't crossing borders. We don't act as if catching 1 positive is worth $75,000.)
People will say "yeah but that person could be the next superspreader!". Sure. But what are the probabilities? If it's 1 in 20 superspreaders you're spending $1.5M per superspreader prevented (N.B. 1 ICU trip is $50,000). This seems like implausibly high odds given vaccination and all the other measures in place; I'd guess that a lot of vaccinated people transmit to 0 others. A trucker coming up then going back might be in that category. Furthermore the PCR test doesn't necessarily catch somebody at peak infectiousness; some won't be infectious at all.
This post of a few facts from the government and mild calls for more rationality/risk calculations would probably be quite controversial in the Canada covid thread.
|
I’ve definitely seen a lot of increased calls to eliminate the test.
It’s extra silly as flights to Canada have vaccine mandates on them now so literally everyone walking through a Canadian airport is vaccinated.. what’s the point then? Even the land border has the US requiring proof of vaccination, meaning that unless you have been in the US since before the reopening of the border, you will have to have been vaccinated. So why are we forcing travellers to spend insane amounts of money and risk to test fully vaccinated individuals?
The whole thing is stupid. And people are starting to figure it out, I imagine once November 8 rolls around the pressure will really mount to eliminate the requirement.
I’m planning a winter vacation to California in March, I hope the testing requirement is lifted by then. I’ll do it if I have to, but it’ll be a giant pain. Otherwise it’ll be weekend visits to Michigan where I can grab my test in Canada on the Friday before I go. Still annoying but not the end of the world.