Quote:
Originally Posted by CrestedSaguaro
Yea, the whole thing is a joke. The noise isn't going to stop with Shady Park and it sets up a precedent that others may try and follow to try and quiet other venues down.
This is what Mill Ave is known for. Mirabella could have easily filled up with younger residents. There really was no reason to build a senior residential tower at the corner of the largest party area in the Phoenix Metro. There should be a clause when signing the lease to accept high levels of noise and if you don't accept it, you don't live there.
I hope the ruling gets appealed.
|
https://kjzz.org/content/1771998/jud...rement-complex has the whole court ruling statement.
It mentions that not just Mirabella residents, but also residents of Union Tempe, Oliv, as well as Westin and Hilton Canopy had issues. If one reads the reviews of Westin and Hilton Canopy one can also find many reviews complaining about noise; some mentioning the Shady Park music volume, some talking about noise from Mill Avenue.
So it is not just Mirabella vs Shady Park; but the various residential complexes and hotels around Shady Park vs Shady Park.
Readers here would have a better idea about when the initial plans regarding the various residential units and hotels in this neighborhood were proposed. My guess is a few of them could predate 2015. (Hotel plans at the Omni location is very old.)