How a ‘Golden Era for Large Cities’ Might Be Turning Into an ‘Urban Doom Loop'
How a ‘Golden Era for Large Cities’ Might Be Turning Into an ‘Urban Doom Loop’
Quote:
Maybe someday I'll be able to afford to live in NYC if it becomes a dump again... |
Quote:
the CB has been estimating big messy legacy cities incorrectly for decades now. something is fundamentally wrong with the models and algorithms they use to compute these things, and yet they don't seem to ever bother adjusting them, despite all of the swinging and missing. a professional ballplayer would start making adjustments to their swing if they had such a cold streak of striking out, but not the CB. |
I mean, it's sure as hell true for SF, Portland, LA, and Seattle. Downtowns across all cities are a shell of what they were 4 years ago. It really sucks. Somehow Canada and Europe doesn't seem to have this phenomenon.
|
I mean, the population data they're citing has to be way off. The residential vacancy rate in Manhattan is lower now than pre-Covid. Apartment rents are at record highs. The parking situation has worsened. So how could there be 200k fewer households than pre-Covid? Aliens?
200k missing households would imply that Manhattan is some Mad Max-level dystopia, with tumbleweeds. You would have half-abandoned neighborhoods. There were 740k households in Manhattan in 2020, so now there are fewer than 540k, yet schools have the same population, retail rents have risen and residential vacancies have dropped? Huh? Manhattan has a giant population of second-home owners, so I could see, peak-Covid, a number of prime neighborhoods temporarily half-empty, but that ended by Fall 2021, at the latest. The really rich neighborhoods are completely "normal" now. The Hamptons are back to a seasonal community. |
This is going to scare all the suburban people who think the "big city" is bad!
-perfect time to finally get a condo in SF that's above the 15th floor. |
Quote:
Don't know about the other cities, but DTLA is more vibrant than ever, at least in the contemporary era. SF's downtown is not doing quite as well, specifically the FiDi for obvious reasons and Union Square. Outside of these areas, within SF proper, the residential neighborhoods are back to pre-pandemic levels of activity, and in some cases, surpassed as new projects come online. |
Quote:
apparently, everything north of the park fell into the hudson. https://i.postimg.cc/59Z6FPCh/madhattan.png |
Here in Pittsburgh, there's been basically a 100% recovery to pre-COVID conditions everywhere outside of Downtown proper. That is to say that all the upscale/gentrified/gentrifying neighborhoods have a robust property market (though it's softening a bit with interest rate hikes) and commercial storefront vacancy isn't notably different than it was prior to the pandemic.
Downtown is still in bad shape, though much better than a year ago. Around half as many office workers still than prior to the pandemic. The City seems to have forced out the homeless people who were camping in vacant storefronts, but there's still a lot of weird loiterers/seeming drug addicts all over the place in Downtown. I don't know if it's higher numbers than prior to the pandemic, but they're more visible with less normal people walking around. The city is already moving towards streamlining residential conversion downtown, and there are hundreds of new units in the pipeline. It's never going to be what it was, but frankly most of the 50% who didn't come back were suburbanites who were only in the city because their job forced them to be. I don't see how a scenario where they're not forced to be somewhere they'd rather not be is actually a positive. |
^ similar in the clev of course, except other way around maybe as downtown is doing very well overall and anytime anyone leaves an office for a hot minute it seems they want to turn it into residential, so they are ahead of pitts in that aspect.
|
Quote:
Next month sometime we will get the state estimates for July 1, 2022. The District of Columbia will give us a direct check on urban rebound, and the New York state change should be largely from NYC itself, so another, more indirect data point. |
An article talking about a 30-year long golden era of large cities, uses (incorrect) stats during pandemic time to declare they are over. What a trash.
|
This is based on mid-Covid numbers. How asinine.
As for Seattle, it's trending in the right direction. Housing construction is booming, vacancy rates are still pretty low despite that, the tents left the Downtown core when a new mayor was elected this year, Downtown retail openings are gaining steam, tourism was huge this summer... Somehow we also keep breaking ground on new office buildings (typically biotech-friendly ones) in the urban core...at least 11 during Covid off the top of my head, including a couple just starting now. |
The expensive overrated cities are definitely getting a wake up call. Turns out ignoring cost of living for the last 20 years was a bad idea. And the pandemic made a lot of people realize their high cost cities were fleecing them, they can get 90%+ of their amenities in much cheaper metros. And nobody wants to spend time or do business in a downtown with tent cities and homeless everywhere.
I'd say Midwest cities besides Chicago and Minneapolis have mostly avoided the total chaos of the last 3 years. With the once in a generation cash infusion from ARPA plus the infrastructure bill, these cities and downtowns are about to look better than they have in a very long time. Really a new golden age for them. |
Reality deniers will say this is all fabricated by right wingers, but in the real world- this is all true.
Cities are not likely to do as well from here on out. Quote:
|
Quote:
The critique here isn't the source, it's the fact that the conclusions are based on monumentally erroneous data. |
While I didn't live in Chicago pre-Covid, the city sure seemed normal to me this past Summer based on all of my previous trips. Maybe 2021 was different, but overall, I felt like the city was just as vibrant this past Summer as any other Summer in Chicago.
Again - A total antidote. |
Not necessarily erroneous, just the wrong data. Who TF doesn't know that mid-2021 was a temporary condition?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
1990: 32,786 2000: 40,836 --- 24.5% 2010: 52,538 --- 28.7% 2020: 74,349 --- 41.5% And we have a thread on the other section showing dozens and dozens towers rising up there, I don't see why you find it so outrageous someone saying Downtown LA is booming. |
Quote:
Or face eating cannibals. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 5:39 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.