1. I'm lazy and busy, I actually made this just so there could be more entry's
2. Renders look fantastic. Aspects of the design are amazing but together I didn't really like the overall composition.
3. This one got my vote. I like the colors, shape and renders. It is a little on the bulky side for its height that is my only critique about it.
4. The top is nice and has a lot of details and so does the bottom but every where in between is pretty boring
5. pretty good design to sharp for my taste though. That shot over Beijing looks crazy cool though.
6. Seems very efficient and the shape isn't bad. The facade is pretty boring and the renders could use some work though.
7. Futuristic evil sci-fi building. It kind of scares me actually. Oh and the palm tree at the base provides a nice touch.

Hmmm. Had a lot of trouble deciding between 4 + 5, but I ultimatly went for the detailing of #4.

So far it looks like #3 is gonna win.

I really regret not entering...I was at first stuck on an idea for an all glass highrise in Miami, but now that the contest is over, I got this really kickin idea of an art-deco inspired megastructure for New York City. Gahhhh!!! :(

Number 3 is definitely my favorite.

I'd love to do the competition, but working on my other supertall project.

I like all the concepts.

If your going to completly ruin the human scale of a city, might as well do it in style. No5.

what is the blacked out building on the far left side of that diagram under No.2?

Kind of disappointed with the designs all around; they all came off ‘cartoony’ so to speak with no real effort to invoke realism.

1.I really couldn’t even get a true picture of the dynamics of the building.
2.Looks like a couple a fancy candlesticks you’d find in an uppity restaurant.
3.Perhaps the most realistic of the bunch, but the whole concept ‘going green’ is becoming utterly boring and repetitive.
4.Looks like something you’d find in a 2050 Moscow if the Soviet Union were still in effect; or from the film Equilibrium.
5.Hopefully we never get to the point where things such as that are visible in skylines.
6.Nice, but a carbon copy of things I’ve seen on an old Discovery Channel show ‘Megastructures’; hence no real originality.
7.In the words of tennis legend Johnny McEnroe: ‘YOU CANNOT BE SERIOUS!’

Here is my review of the buildings:

1.Looks nice and all, but not really any "green works" and maybe a couple of more pics. Nice try though
2.I really think they tried way too hard on this. You can't possibly think this could be built! Beautful details!
3. one of the best on here.Maybe a little more less on the "green" and more on the building.It also looks kinda boring.
4.Like MikeR said I love the top and the middle but everything else pretty much blends in.
5.Way too much for me. Good details.
6.This one is my favorite. I like the design and how it fits in. Though it looks a lot like SkyCity.It also took some of its name.
7. There is too much on it and I don't the the top part of it.

Damn Dac you seems like your in a good mood today
Obviously none of them are 3000 foot international style boxes so of course your not going to be happy with the designs

Haha, moods just fine mike, but I’m not going to pretend to like these designs for the sake of preventing anyone from getting teary eyed. Don’t be afraid to speak your mind; there isn’t a Mona Lisa amongst the bunch here, we all know that.

.
 

:previous: well your honest in your opinion dac.
but what seemed at first like an easy comp turned
out to be probaly the most difficult..modeling something
so tall aint easy so well done to all efforts;)

I didn't manage to vote on time, but my vote would have gone to no. 5, bringing this competition to a tie. No. 3 looked really realistic, but somehow it didn't feel like it was almost a kilometer high. More like 300 meters.

Anyways, great entries, everyone!

Wow, already closed? I didn't think 5 days would go so fast... should I open it for 2 more days?

I think the majority of people who were going to vote have voted. Can we just discuss how we did now?

Assuming that the competition is actually over, I am going to talk about my piece. I lost pretty bad so it doesn't matter if I get disqualified if Aleks restarts voting, so I will just say that I put in entry number four.

I aimed for a massive Art Deco work with mine. I learned a lot about general construction techniques with this project, you can actually glimpse some curtains I managed to make myself in the main lobby.

My biggest issue with this project was my own technical limitation. Kerkythea would not render it with the amount of lights I put in it, so I had to change render settings and reduce the number of spot lights.

The crown was actually going to have a brilliant stainless steel top, but it wouldn't render right. Neither would silver. Was really annoying that Kerky didn't want to do what I wanted.

I couldn't think of what to put towards the middle of the tower. I should have probably added more "tiers" to it.

Edit: However, I think I did way better with this comp compared to the last comp I was in.

I just think the designs in general didn’t seem to strike any realism; they seemed to stem more off of fantasy. None of them looked really rushed, minus a couple, but by and large it seems that much time was dedicated to them.

Krases, the detail in yours was actually quite well thought out, but the killer was the proportions. I agree with your point; more setbacks might have done it more justice.

Yeah I think if I had more stuff to simply express scale better it would have helped. I actually had an idea in which I would place a grand neon-decorated shopping area inside.

The only part I admit to rushing was the stairs around the base and the canopys. I was running out of time and just couldn't come up with a good idea, but I needed something.

Alright then! I'll contact the winner and announce him on the next comp!

Just wanted to say it was cool to be in the comp, my first time! Hopefully I can find time in my studies to participate again sometime. Cheers from #2.

Congrats to burjdubai91 , Looks like there is at least 160 floors there so it does hit the height mark. :cool:



Some points on my model -

This IS what you will be seeing in the future- future = fantasy !
I don't like it either but in 10 years or so when a new WTB is built it will probably be attractive.

Practicality ? I PUT IN FLOORPLANS !!!!

Actually i made it so real that i am going to continue to work on it.:cool:

Thanks. :P