Quote:
Originally Posted by M II A II R II K
|
This really is a silly article, and seems to be written by someone who doesn't understand commuting patterns in the NYC area.
No, a subway tunnel to/from Lower Manhattan wouldn't make more sense. There are already two subway lines heading from NJ to Lower Manhattan. It's called PATH.
And Midtown has more than three times the employment and visitor base. Obviously it makes more sense to bring commuters to Midtown.
As for Jamaica Station vs. Secaucus Station, folks transfer at Jamaica because they have to! Many trains terminate at Jamaica, and many trips require a transfer. Not a single train terminates at Secaucus, so obviously there are fewer transfers.
And Jamaica runs an underground LIRR line to downtown Brooklyn (Atlantic Avenue terminal), so there's a second major endpoint destination. There is only one major endpoint option from Secaucus (yes, there's Hoboken terminal, but it's a somewhat smaller jobs hub).