Quote:
Originally Posted by XIII
|
An unfortunate trend with this new crop of infill that is double the height or more of the average building on the block is that the developers are making the mass of these buildings visually horizontally disposed (excepting 1611 Division, which does an admirable job of adding vertically to what is basically a cube). Presumably, this is to placate neighborhood groups and aldermen since the buildings don't look "tall", but the irony is that they end up being
more incongruous with their environment when they are built because they are being dropped into blocks that have mostly vertically-oriented buildings (also, every other detail of the facade is usually over-scaled, and this contributes to incongruency just as much, IMO--see Belmont/Clark). You end up with a big, wide pile of building that pushes out to its sides against its neighbors rather than gracefully ascending with them (albeit above and beyond in the case of extra height, which I have no problem with). People also need to realize that a building's true height is rarely perceived; effects of shadowing aside, the psycho-difference between a 3-story building and a 7-story one when viewed at an oblique angle (walking down a sidewalk of the block the building is on, for instance) is a fraction of the absolute difference.