Quote:
Originally Posted by dc_denizen
unions exist to prevent working class labor from being exploited by capital in a capitalistic system. Teachers unions, in this context, make zero sense. who is exploiting teachers, the taxpayer? are teachers being asked to work dangerous, long hours for minimum wage, while producing profits that go solely to asset owners? no. so whats the need for these unions?
Meanwhile these unions make sure that teachers can continue teaching despite years of poor results and complaints; can take paid leave if they get in trouble (see: NY times articles on the subject, also https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content..._chapter.pdf); and favor a senority system that rewards years of service over merit and results.
|
Lets start by noting that Teacher qualifications and pay/benefits range widely across U.S. states and individual school boards.
But while some U.S. teachers are brilliant and well paid.
Others are not qualified to work in schools in other states let alone in any other OECD Country.
Equally, while some U.S. teachers are very well paid; others are paid only slightly more than entry level wages.
Finally, lets note that many US teachers do work in less than stellar conditions, some in schools in poor repair or with safety concerns...........
Others....with well over 30 pupils per teacher.
Those in better conditions w/more qualifications, show the utility of a union.
While those who endure something worse.........show the problems of not having an effective one.