Quote:
Originally Posted by Stryker
What your contrasting is democracy versus autocracy.
Has nothing to do with capitalism or communism.
Ironically the most guilty of the anti democratic actions in the west are always the right wing parties. Harper being a prime example of a person who has contempt for democracy.
The fact that capitalism is associated with democracy is completely an american folklore and has no basis in reality.
|
Stryker,
I was referring to the USSR example you alluded to before. It was a failure because extreme socialist economies can only exist in a non-democratic environment. True command economies require a state structure that is not only powerful but has disproportionate instruments of "command" to achieve its economic and social objectives, in other words goons (police, army, empowered bureaucracy).
If people try to vote out a regime as people tend to do from time to time in democracies, that regime will do anything to maintain their authority and power. The more power ("command" control), the less likely a regime change and more likely a suppression of democracy is likely to occur. Even the sweetest of people will turn into power hungry autocrats if you give them unnatural power, it's human nature. This why so many fight attempts to create more state control in democratic capitalist societies. While I agree that stronger social programs for those at the very bottom are a must, greater control of anything more is a recipe for disaster.
Once again, balance is key.