Quote:
Originally Posted by PDXDENSITY
I'm excited about this line getting finished. I really hope there is more interest in a SW MAX line since Powell has been completely taken off that list. On an aside, I think BRT on Powell will be done horribly if it is not completely grade separated; which then begs the question, why not a cheaper to maintain rail line.
|
Rail is cheaper to operate, but more expensive to maintain than pavement w/rails. The Powell line has ROW for separated ROW from about SE 50th to SE 82nd, then on Division most of the way to Gresham. Routing it along SE 92nd to avoid some traffic has also been discussed.
If it could be grade separated it would be light rail, but the overhead lines, tracks, etc all make rail a more expensive choice if the ROW isn't available for dedicated lanes. The FRA doesn't let you mix light rail with cars, and streetcar just isn't really a good fit for the length of the commute.
Buses with all the features of light rail doesn't seem that bad. The platforms will be like MAX where you're expected to get a ticket before you board, you can use multiple doors to get on/off the vehicle, there won't need to ride for ten stops to go thirty blocks, and buses won't need to just keep going because they're too full. BRT can share stations with local buses. You don't need to build separate waiting areas for rail and bus passengers.
The BRT option isn't perfect, but as long as the keep the local 9 and 4, and let it share stops with the future Powell BRT I'll have no complaints.
Light rail and streetcar have good uses, but on a major state highway like Powell BRT seems like a pretty good compromise. Without a tunnel/elevated structure there was no reasonable way to connect light rail from about SE 39th to the Powell/Orange Line overpass.
Oh, and from the meeting I went to it could be open by 2020, whereas light rail under the same optimistic outlook would take until about 2026 to open. I live near Powell, and I'd love to have light rail. Right now we might as well preserve the ROW we have (parking lanes/areas on Division and Powell) for transit use even if we can't install rails yet.
I bet in 50 years people will appreciate that more than adding more highway lanes.