Buskers complain pilot project falls short on easing restrictions
City monitors response to revamped rules
Tamara Gignac, Calgary Herald
Published: Thursday, August 21, 2008
On the first day of a pilot project to ease restrictions for downtown buskers, some local jugglers, musicians and mimes say they still face too many rules compared to street entertainers in other major cities.
Buskers, beginning Wednesday, could perform on sidewalks from the Beltline to Prince's Island Park and 14th Street S.W. to City Hall without being limited to designated "busk stops" or having to obtain permits.
The only rules are no juggling dangerous or flammable objects, no amplifiers and performers are not allowed to stay in one spot for longer than an hour.
Janet Jessiman of the Downtown Calgary Association called the project -- slated to run for six months -- a boost to the city's culture and arts community.
"Buskers bring life and entertainment to the people. We've started a new trend with no licences . . . let's keep things going that way," she said, speaking Wednesday with buskers at a public forum at Olympic Plaza.
But some -- like fire-eater Stephanie Norn, say the restrictions are still too rigid.
Norn, a professionally trained circus performer, vehemently agrees that rules should exist to prevent novice entertainers from handling dangerous objects like knives and swords on city streets. But she points to European cities, where qualified fire manipulators routinely busk for money in public venues.
"If we just set a blanket statement that says, 'No, you perform with fire, therefore you're not allowed,' then we are going to miss a richness and diversity of performers, the kind of thing that is a staple in other cities," said Norn.
Others at the forum raised questions about the no-amplification rule, which they say makes it difficult for musicians with acoustic guitars and other performers to be heard at larger venues such as Prince's Island Park.
Beth Gignac, the city's manager of arts and culture, said the pilot project is a work in progress, and feedback from buskers will be evaluated on a monthly basis.
As an example, she points to the amplification restriction, which some cities have dealt with by requiring performers to keep noise below an acceptable decibel. "We want to figure out if there's a way for us to have amplified sound and where those places could be," said Gignac.
"Because we've opened this up to the broader downtown, some people are saying they're OK with it, some people are saying they're not."
Karen Sim, a violinist and singer who has performed outdoors in Calgary for a decade, acknowledges the restrictions may not be perfect for everyone, but hopes the rules will evolve as people grow more accustomed to seeing performers on downtown streets.
"A lot of parallels have been drawn between busking and panhandling -- the idea that we're out to make a buck and don't really care how we do it," she said.
"But we're out here for myriad reasons. Calgary is our home and we have a chance to share what we do and who we are."
tgignac@theherald.canwest.com
© The Calgary Herald 2008
===============================
http://www.canada.com/calgaryherald/...5-673d521ac2e2