With the civic election today, I've been doing some ruminating on the future of the old
Moncton High School, and the possibility of relocating the Moncton Public Library to a potential MHS redevelopment (as envisaged by the MH35 group).
- Brian Hicks is in favour of relocating the library.
- Dawn Arnold is in favour of keeping the library as part of the Blue Cross Centre, and right next to the Downing Street Plaza project.
Here is the site plan for the MH35 proposal:
The MH35 group feels that a relocated library is a keystone of the proposal, and that the project to save Moncton High School likely wouldn't go ahead without it. With Dawn Arnold the probable winner in today's election, this would tend to place the MH35 proposal at risk.
I wonder if there isn't another way forward- perhaps a third option to move away from this impasse.
According to most people, the real jewels of MHS are the old auditorium and the new gymnasium. In the above site plan, this conforms to the grey coloured area and the adjacent orange coloured "centre of excellence". This is what people
really want saved. The Atlantic Ballet Theatre of Canada would be moving into this space.
I humbly suggest that the Centre of Excellence and the auditorium be saved at all costs, with other alternatives explored for the future of the remainder of the building.
The simplest thing to do would be to demolish this portion of the old high school and use the land as a parking lot for the new Atlantic Ballet Theatre. In other words, a partial renovation/partial demolition. I don't think anyone has brought this forward as a proposal before. A benefit of this could be that the proposed lobby addition to the building could be moved to the north, and away from the historic main entrance to the building, thus preserving the buildings facade.
the current MH35 proposal would replace this:
with this:
I've always been unsettled by this. The facade of the entrance is the defining feature of MHS. I have never been a fan of covering it up with a glass box. By demolishing the north wing of the high school and relocating the new lobby to the north, the original facade gets preserved.
A partial renovation/partial demolition would save the important parts of MHS, and at the same time keep the public library in it's bright and cheery location in the Blue Cross Centre. It might even be cheaper than a wholesale renovation and relocation. A win-win situation perhaps?
Thoughts anyone.........